Surgical Error
Surgical error cases involve patient harm caused by preventable mistakes during operative procedures, including wrong-site surgery, retained surgical instruments, intraoperative organ or nerve injuries, and anesthesia-related complications during surgery. These cases are distinct from general malpractice claims because they focus specifically on events that occurred in the operating room, where the standard of care encompasses not only the surgeon's technical skill but also preoperative planning, intraoperative decision-making, the surgical team's adherence to safety protocols, and postoperative recognition and management of complications. Expert testimony is essential to establish what occurred during the procedure, whether it constituted a deviation from the standard of care, and whether the error caused the patient's injury as opposed to a recognized and consented-to risk of the procedure.
Surgical experts evaluate the entire operative episode, from preoperative planning through postoperative care. The expert assesses whether the surgical indication was appropriate, whether the preoperative workup was adequate, and whether the informed consent process disclosed the material risks of the procedure. Intraoperatively, the expert evaluates surgical technique, the adequacy of the surgical time-out and site verification, instrument and sponge counts, the use of intraoperative imaging or monitoring, and the management of complications that arose during the procedure. Postoperatively, the expert evaluates whether complications were recognized in a timely manner and whether the surgeon's response met the standard of care. In retained instrument cases, the expert evaluates the counting protocol, the use of radiographic detection, and whether the retained object caused the patient's symptoms.
The required surgical specialty matches the procedure at issue. General surgery experts address laparoscopic and open abdominal procedures, hernia repairs, and cholecystectomy complications. Orthopedic surgery experts evaluate joint replacement, fracture fixation, and arthroscopic procedure errors. Neurosurgery experts assess craniotomy, spinal surgery, and shunt placement complications. Cardiac surgery experts address coronary bypass and valve replacement errors. OB/GYN experts evaluate hysterectomy, cesarean delivery, and laparoscopic gynecologic surgery errors. Anesthesiology experts assess anesthesia-related injuries including airway complications, regional anesthesia nerve injuries, and medication errors in the operative setting. Operating room nursing experts evaluate safety protocol compliance.
Surgical error experts must demonstrate that their opinions distinguish between a recognized complication of the procedure, which may occur in the absence of negligence, and a preventable surgical error that represents a deviation from the standard of care. Under Daubert, the expert must base this distinction on accepted surgical principles, published complication rates, anatomic knowledge, and the specific facts documented in the operative report and medical record. The expert must show current surgical experience with the procedure at issue and familiarity with the safety protocols, including the WHO Surgical Safety Checklist, that apply to the operative setting.
Tell us about your case and we will match you with a qualified expert within 48 hours.